Discrimination doesn’t solve discrimination


The reaction from some of the more radical Maori to Judith Collins saying it is time to change the tikanga which doesn’t allow women to speak on some marae reminded me of this anecdote told by Paul Foster-Bell.

He was standing for National in Wellington Central and began his speech at the Aro Valley meet the candidates meeting by speaking in te reo.

The audience were conflicted between a very obvious desire to show no respect to him as a National MP and not wishing to disrespect the language.

Showing more respect to one language someone uses than another might be minor discrimination but it is still discrimination.

Apropos of that is this comment from Theodore Dalrymple:

. . . it continues to surprise me how little protest there is against the very expression racial justice, than which few expressions could be more racist . . .

All of which was prompted by this tweet:

Sexism is sexism wherever it happens.

Treating someone differently because of their gender, race or any other of the categories identity politics highlights is always discriminatory.

And discrimination isn’t solved by more discrimination.

Juan Carlos abdicates


When we lived in Spain some of the people we met could remember life under Franco and the transition to democracy under King Juan Carlos.

It’s fairly recent history.

On a lighter note the news has prompted these tweets:


Paul Foster-Bell Nat candidate for Wellington Central


National Party members have selected Paul Foster-Bell as their candidate for Wellington Central.

The National Party has announced List MP and former diplomat Paul Foster-Bell will be its candidate for the Wellington Central electorate at the 2014 General Election.

Mr Foster-Bell was selected by a meeting of local party members tonight.

“Paul was an outstanding candidate in 2011 and has made an excellent contribution as a List MP based in Wellington and the Hutt Valley for the past ten months. I congratulate him on his selection,” said Lower North Island Regional Chair Malcolm Plimmer.

Mr Foster-Bell says he is delighted to have been selected again in Wellington Central, and is looking forward to the challenge ahead.

“I’m deeply honoured to be selected as National’s candidate for Wellington Central and look forward to taking National’s positive message to the electorate, seeking to further increase our party vote here in particular,” said Mr Foster-Bell.

“National is delivering real progress for Wellingtonians. I’ve been proud to support the Government’s work to improve our region’s transport networks, fund landmark projects such as the National War Memorial, invest in a cleaner environment, and deliver significant improvements in healthcare and education.                                                                                                                        

“I will be working hard to ensure Wellington Central retains a strong voice in
John Key’s National Party.”

Paul Foster Bell – Biographical Notes

Paul Foster-Bell is currently a National List MP, entering Parliament in 2013 after a distinguished career in foreign affairs. He was promoted to Deputy Chair of the Justice and Electoral Select Committee earlier this year.

Raised on a farm in Northland, Paul was educated at Whangarei Boys’ High School, went on to study archaeology and business at Otago University, and took courses in history at Oxford University.

Paul’s entry into politics followed an exceptional diplomatic career, including roles promoting trade and protecting New Zealand’s national interests as Deputy Head of Mission in Tehran – also accredited to Afghanistan and Pakistan. He served most recently as Deputy Head of Mission and Head of Chancery at the New Zealand Embassy in Riyadh. Paul has also worked on investment, national security, protocol, and Middle East and Africa affairs at MFAT’s head office in Wellington.

Paul was a Young Nat in Dunedin when I was the party’s Otago Electorate chair.

He stood for the party in Dunedin South in 2002.

He is a good example of someone prepared to take on a red seat to help the party then gain work experience before returning to politics.

Paul Foster-Bell’s maiden speech


Paul Foster-Bell delivered his maiden speech this evening:

E nga mana, e nga reo, e nga karanga maha e huihui nei, Tena Koutou Katoa!

Mr Speaker. Members. Family, friends and supporters.

It is with a mixture of exhilaration, trepidation and aspiration that I rise to make a maiden statement in this 50th Parliament of New Zealand.

I am delighted to be joining the parliamentary team of the National Party led by the

Right Honourable John Key. National is, I believe, the only party capable of leading the sound, stable, and steady government this country needs. This Government is delivering the increased economic growth rates, thriving and safer communities, efficient public services, and personal freedoms which all Kiwis want and deserve.

I congratulate the Prime Minister and his excellent ministers for their unstinting work in untangling the mess created by nine years of socialist misrule, and in leading this nation to a brighter future in years to come.

It is a real honour to serve as an elected representative of the people of our beautiful country. At the same time, it is almost impossible not to be awestruck by one’s weighty responsibilities as a new MP: enacting the laws of the land, scrutinising government expenditure, assisting constituents with their issues, and having input into the policy of the governing party must all be taken very seriously.

I intend to keep my head down and learn from older and wiser members. I am grateful to Hon Chris Finlayson QC, the Hon Judith Collins, the Hon Tony Ryall, the

Hon Nick Smith, and the National MPs of the 2011 intake in particular, as well as all the National Party team, for their advice and warm welcome into this House.

Mr Speaker, I particularly look forward to being a Member in this House when the National War Memorial Park is opened in Wellington, where I am based. The centenary of Gallipoli marks a momentous event in our evolution towards independent nationhood a hundred years ago – and the plaques in this chamber commemorating that campaign, and others in which New Zealanders have fought, serve as a constant reminder to members of the Kiwi lives lost to secure our democracy and defend our way of life.

As John Key said, the National War Memorial Park will be a significant legacy to commemorate the centenary of Anzac Day. It is a special gift to the Capital and will become a wonderful civic amenity as well as a focal point for national commemorations. Earlier plans for a National War Memorial park fell by the wayside through neglect by the previous government, and the current precinct remained divided by State Highway 1 – until Chris Finlayson and Gerry Brownlee set out to deliver on a vision for an upgraded Buckle Street area.

I look forward to supporting other initiatives which will contribute to Wellington remaining a thriving, wonderful place to live.

Mr Speaker, given a maiden speech is one of the very few occasions in this Chamber when a member may make reference to guests in the public galleries, I ask that you indulge me in mentioning a few special people who are here today.

I would like to acknowledge president Peter Goodfellow, the board of the National Party – in particular Lower North Island chair Malcolm Plimmer and the lovely Linda – and all the office holders, activists, and members of the party.

I am very grateful for the help of our wonderful people locally in Wellington.

I was most fortunate to have as my campaign chair Brett Hudson, who put in an enormous effort during the 2011 election. I would also like to thank stalwart campaign and executive committee members: Dr Pat McCarthy, Murray Radford, Richard and Elaine Westlake, Sir Christopher and Lady Anna Harris, Graeme and Judith Sugden, Peter Milne, Alistair Scott, Aaron Hape, Chloe Oldfield, Brian Anderton, Carolyn O’Fallon, Carsten Schousboe, Carina Aiken, Haimona Gray, Jim Guo, Dr Joe Rousseau, Bridget-Anne Fowler, Rainer McAlister, Victor Cauty, Lliam Munro, Dr Rosy Fenwicke, Julian Light, and Henry Williams – as well as Cameron Pickering who has come up from Christchurch and Lyndon Crabbe from Roxburgh.

Many thanks to the Super Blues, especially Nancy McDonald, Joan Farrance, Pam Finlayson, Bernie Poole, and Patricia Morrison for their kind assistance. Thank you David Farrar and Neil Miller for the useful guidance. We were also very well supported by an exceptional group at Party HQ: Jo, Greg, Cam, Liam, Donna, Beth, and Sean. And to the hundreds of volunteers who gave so much of their time, thank you all so much.

I want to make special mention of the Young Nats. This was the group that gave me my start in politics, and I am thrilled that they have never been in such good heart and strength on campuses around the country as they are today. I would like to acknowledge Daniel Fielding who led the Young Nats over three years up to this high point, Sean Topham who is capably chairing it today, Christian Hermansen who chairs the regional Young Nats, and Joel Rowan from our local VicNats branch.

The Young Nats have won some real victories on longstanding youth issues in recent years: lobbying successfully to remove compulsion from student unions, keeping the age for purchase of alcohol at 18, addressing teen depression and suicide, and supporting equal access to marriage for all Kiwis. I hope the Young Nats keep rattling cages, and keep me on my toes as a new MP.

To friends who could not make it today – Malcolm and Marian Cone in Temuka, Peter and Sarah Walker and Robyn Broughton in Dunedin; Ele Ludemann in Oamaru, Professor John and Jenny Leader in Blenheim; Emma Mellow-Sandford in Sydney; Tiffany in Canberra; Kezia in England; Geoff and Chris Pope in Seattle; the Cammock Family in Jakarta; Johnny and Chantal Rayner-Burt along with my godson Hugo in Italy – I am most grateful for the loyal support I have consistently received over the years.

And, most importantly, I would like to pay tribute to my family.

To my parents – Bob and Alyse – a child could not have had a better start in life than I got, thanks to you. The example set by you Dad – of putting your family above all other concerns, and working every hour of the day to provide for them – is an outstanding one.

And Mum, the lesson you taught us that learning is something to be treasured, and with a sound education the world is one’s oyster, is something that I hope – one day – every Kiwi kid will be inculcated with. I couldn’t be prouder that after more than 30 years of part-time study you are on the cusp of completing your PhD.

I would also like to send special greetings to my brother and sister, Greg and Shaan, my niece, Caitlin, and granddad Ayers Robert Foster Sr, who will be watching this on the TV in Whangarei along with Dulcie. And warm regards to my Aunty Eleanor Ashcroft, who will be tuned in along with Vic Reid, in Rotorua.

Mr Speaker, I have been privileged to have served our country both on and offshore in the foreign service over the past nine years. It was a real pleasure to work for some of the most capable and dedicated senior officials in this country’s public sector: ambassadors Hamish MacMaster, Brian Sanders, Rod Harris, Malcolm Millar,

Dr Jonathan Austin, Dr James Kember, and Wendy Hinton – as well as some absolutely first rate colleagues and workmates – both Kiwis and locally engaged.

I have also enjoyed a range of experiences overseas which few visitors to distant lands get – including seeing, from a behind the scenes perspective, how a number of other countries really operate.

Mr Speaker, of all the countries I worked in, none is as free as

New Zealand. Some, such as Iran, would actually fall at the opposite end of any objective scale measuring corruption, transparency, and rule of law.

Thankfully, it is the people of New Zealand – not the State – who have, to a larger degree than almost anywhere else in the world, power over their own lives and the ability to decide their own prospects for the future. This reminds me of a quote from the late, great Baroness Thatcher of our right “to have the State as servant and not as master … on that freedom, all our other freedoms depend”. This is just as true today as when the Iron Lady first said it.

We should be rightly proud of the advances towards freedom which we have made. But there are areas where further work is needed, in my view, if we are to retain our place as a country where liberty and freedom of speech, of thought, of belief and of action are most cherished. The abolition of blasphemy as a criminal offence, for which one can be imprisoned for up to a year, is one example of such an area crying out for reform.

Mr Speaker, of all the countries I spent time in, none is as clean, green and endowed with such a pristine natural environment and spectacular scenic splendour as

New Zealand. In demonstrating that economic growth and preserving environmental values can go hand in hand, and showing that good science is essential to high quality environmental decision making, New Zealand is leading the way.

I am glad that New Zealanders are able to enjoy our unique birth right, to access our special places: the beaches, rivers, lakes, and mountains for which our land is rightly renowned.

Mr Speaker, of all the other jurisdictions I have worked in, none is as well served by their public servants as ours. Across a range of departments from MFAT, the Treasury and MBIE, through to Defence, the security services, the Police and the Prime Minister’s Department, I have worked in a state sector which has seen increasing levels of resource shifted from bureaucracy and administration to delivering the services New Zealanders need; which is operating more efficiently than ever before; and which is carrying out this Government’s policies to achieve unprecedented positive results. Results like the lowest crime rate in a generation or record numbers of elective surgeries for those who need them.

Mr Speaker, of the developed economies I have visited, few are as well positioned as New Zealand to ride out the world’s current period of economic instability and to take advantage of the opportunities offered by exporting to a rapidly growing Asian middle class; or by servicing the food security needs of the prosperous but arid Gulf States; or by hosting increasingly high value tourists and students from abroad in our safe, tolerant, and welcoming nation.

None of this is to say that we have all the answers here in our island home. Quite the opposite. There is a lot we can learn from other successful smaller states, such as Singapore, or the UAE. And, of course, as a small trading nation we are utterly dependent on our trading partners and a stable, rules-based world order to ensure our own future prosperity.

Our first woman Prime Minister, Rt Hon Dame Jenny Shipley, tidily summed this concept up when she said that “New Zealand needs the world a heck of a lot more than the rest of the world needs New Zealand”. This sentiment certainly echoes my experiences, representing our country out in the field.

Mr Speaker, the National Party was founded 77 years ago as a coalition between sectors which were diverse in origins, but which had aligning interests and shared objectives.

National’s founders were those in the productive sector – whether farmers or urban manufacturers.

They were those in business, both employers and employees, professionals practising on their own account, or tradesmen.

They were those hardworking mothers and fathers who aspired to a better life for their children and equal treatment for everyone, irrespective of colour, creed or class.

They were those who valued property rights for themselves and others, and who wanted a limited government which encouraged free enterprise and rewards for effort.

National is still the bastion of equal opportunity and the rule of law. These timeless values are why the public has elected National to the treasury benches for 40 of the past 60 years. Our party continues to govern in the interest of all New Zealanders, and that is why I am proud to call myself a National Party Member.

Mr Speaker, I have come to this esteemed place to do more than simply occupy a seat.

Sir, I have come to this House to support sound economic management, growth, and sensible public spending. I stand firmly against ruinously high borrowing, inefficient public services, or incentivising irresponsibility through unfettered welfare.

I have come to this House, Sir, to back the Prime Minister and his Government. I am resolutely opposed to socialism and its overweening conceit that redistribution, and governmental meddling in private enterprise can deliver positive outcomes for our people. They cannot. In the words of Sir Winston Churchill, “for a nation to tax itself into prosperity is like a man standing in a bucket and trying to lift himself up by the handle”.

I have come to this House, Sir, as a champion for trade, tourism, and closer linkages with other countries, and the transformative effects these can bring through higher incomes, and more employment. I repudiate xenophobia and protectionism, which damage our overseas relationships, our reputation, and our earnings.

Mr Speaker, I have come to this House to advocate strongly for our capital city, and for all the residents of Wellington Central and Hutt South.

I have come to this House, Sir, as a Blue Green. I want to see pragmatic protections for our stunning natural environment, balanced against the need to derive economic benefits from our natural resources where appropriate. I will criticise impractical and Luddite responses to environmental challenges.

I have come to this House, Sir, as a Blue Liberal, and a defender of diversity, liberty, and equal treatment by the State for all its citizens. I will be a trenchant enemy of any laws which seek to implement the hideous apparatus of the police state here in New Zealand. In the words of our National Anthem, “May our mountains ever be, freedom’s ramparts on the sea”.

I have come to this House, Sir, as a proponent of the Constitutional Monarchy which has served us so well for over 170 years. I will fiercely resist any measures which weaken this essential pillar of our robust democracy.

Mr Speaker, to paraphrase Alfred, Lord Tennyson – I have come to this House made weak by time and fate, but strong in will: to seek, to strive, to find, and not to yield.

I look forward to working with you, Sir, and all likeminded members to achieve these goals.

Thank you.

You can see and hear him deliver the speech at Parliament Today.

Loyalty and perseverance pays off


Paul Foster-Bell will become an MP at the end of May when Jackie Blue leaves parliament to become Equal Opportunities Commissioner.

. . .Mr Foster-Bell is currently on posting with MFAT as Deputy Head of Mission at the New Zealand Embassy in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. His previous appointments include Deputy Director for the Middle East and Africa, Deputy Chief of Protocol, First Secretary and Consul at the New Zealand Embassy in Tehran, and Regional Manager within MFAT’s Security Directorate.

He is an archaeologist by training, has a business diploma from the University of Otago, and also studied history at Oxford.

He was active in the National Party in Dunedin when he was a student and stood in Dunedin South although he knew he wouldn’t win the electorate  and at that stage was very unlikely to gain a list seat.

He stayed loyal, stood again in Wellington Central last year and now will enter parliament.

Some people question why anyone would stand in a seat they couldn’t win.

A good campaign will help with the party vote and won’t go unnoticed.

Paul’s journey to parliament shows the willingness to take on tiger country can be part of a longer game and that perseverance  and loyalty pay off.

His campaign experience and work history will both be assets in his career as an MP.

Paul Foster-Bell MP to be?


A media release from  former MP Paul Quinn says he will not return to parliament when list MP Jackie Blue retires to become Equal Opportunities Commissioner in May.

With the resignation of my former colleague Dr Jackie Blue I am the next eligible member of the National Party list to fill the vacancy her resignation has created.

While I enjoyed the term I spent in Parliament from 2008 to 2011, I do not wish to take up the list place available to me. Since leaving Parliament I have been engaged in a series of commercial projects that are very absorbing and satisfying and I am now fully committed to my expanding business interests. . .

Paul Foster-Bell who stood in Wellington Central is the next person on National’s list.

Blue out, Paul who in?


National list MP Jackie Blue is to take up a new role as Equal Opportunities Commissioner in June.

Justice Minister Judith Collins said:

“The EEO Commissioner has an important role to play in championing EEO principles, issues and practices in New Zealand as well as appreciating their relationship to social, economic and labour market trends.

“Dr Blue is committed to human rights and equity issues and is currently the Chair of three cross-party groups in Parliament. I’m confident she will be a very capable Commissioner.”

Dr Blue has a Private Members’ Bill in the ballot seeking to protect young women from forced marriages. I hope another MP takes up this issue.

Dr Blue holds a BSc from the University of Auckland and gained her MB ChB from Auckland Medical School in 1983. She came to prominence in the medical sector as a pioneering breast physician and, in 1992, was a founding member of the St Marks Women’s Health Centre. Dr Blue entered Parliament as a list MP in 2005 and has since held a number of roles including membership of the Health Committee (2005 to 2008).

She is currently the Chair of three cross-party groups in Parliament – New Zealand Parliamentarian’s Group on Population and Development, Commonwealth Women Parliamentarians and Parliamentarians for Global Action. Dr Blue is also a member of the Justice & Electoral Committee and Deputy Chairperson of the Health Committee.

Her resignation from parliament will open the way for another MP.

The next person on National’s list is former MP Paul Quinn. If he chooses not to take up the vacancy the next one of the list if Paul Foster-Bell.

Diversity in electorates takes pressure off list


Damien O’Connor was criticised for the intemperate language he used to describe the Labour list.

His criticism shouldn’t have been directed at the list, one of its roles is supposed to be to add to the diversity of parliament.

The question to ask of Labour is why doesn’t it have much diversity among its electorate MPs?

Labour’s selection is strongly influenced by unions and head office which makes it relatively easy to select people who don’t fit the WMM (white middle-aged male) category as candidates for red seats.

In National, providing an electorate has 200 members, it is they who select the candidate and the party hierarchy has no influence at all over who they select.

In spite or because of that, Kiwiblog points out, National has eight MPs of Maori descent now.

Georgina te Heuheu is retiring in November but the party has new candidates of Maori descent in Northland (Mike Sabin), Wellington Central (Paul Foster-Bell), Dunedin South (Joanne Hayes) and Mangare (Claudette Hauiti).

That means 11 out of 63 National candidates in general seats are of Maori descent.

Is part of Labour’s problem the Maori seats? Has it taken for granted it would win them and thought that means it doesn’t need Maori in general seats?

Perhaps if Labour trusted its members and exercised a little more democracy in selecting candidates for electorates,  it wouldn’t have to depend so much on its list to get a caucus more representative of New Zealand.


 Apropos of yesterday’s post on participation, National’s Northland selection would be the most democratic of any for any party in the country. It was made by 275 voting delegates representing a membership of more than 4,000.

%d bloggers like this: