Wait for the outcry

08/02/2012

Harvard University’s endowment fund has made a profit from its investment in Maniototo dairy farms:

DF1, the New Zealand dairy farmer owned by Harvard University’s endowment fund, posted a profit of $4.87 million last year, having bought the Big Sky Dairy Farm properties in central Otago from their receivers.

Harvard paid about $32 million for the Ainwick, Tercio and Saran farms on the Maniototo Plain, having gained Overseas Investment Office approval for the purchases in September 2010. Big Sky was the biggest dairy farm operator in Central Otago when it defaulted on payments in 2007 and was placed in liquidation in 2009.

DF1’s accounts for the year ended June 30, 2011, show Harvard picked up assets worth almost $34 million in the deal. The company notes Big Sky was in receivership,“hence the resultant discount on acquisition.”

Revenue surged to $11.2 million in 2011 from about $1.6 million a year earlier, when it recorded a $1.2 million loss, DF1’s accounts show. The Big Sky farms are being managed alongside DF1’s existing dairy property, Helenslea.

People opposed to foreign investment will criticise this return on investment.

They won’t take any notice of the people the company employs, the money spent on farm running expenses, repairs and maintenance or the tax paid.

The fund also owns forests and those who think the state should have retained ownership of them should ponder this:

The natural resources portfolio has been built up during the last decade by Andy Wiltshire, a New Zealander who started his career with the New Zealand Forest Service, the developer of the Kaingaroa plantation forest in the central North Island. Wiltshire is head of external management for Harvard Management, the fund’s manager.

Harvard beat out China’s Citic to buy the Kaingaroa cutting rights from receivership in 2004. The price was not disclosed but it was believed to be near US$650 million. The same forest was sold by the Crown in 1996 for $2.2 billion.

I don’t know why the value dropped from $2.2 billion to around $US650 million but I’m pleased it wasn’t the state who took the loss.


%d bloggers like this: