Labour chose the wrong couple as the poster children for its housing policy:
David Cunliffe is backing the party’s choice of a couple used as a case study for Labour’s housing policy, after the pair conceded they weren’t actually looking to buy.
The Labour party leader and the party’s housing spokesman Phil Twyford confirmed Labour’s KiwiBuild policy at a housing development in Hobsonville yesterday with a young couple who Mr Cunliffe said would benefit from the policy. . . .
Ms Leigh said they were currently living with her parents and although they had “had a look at houses in the Auckland area” she conceded they weren’t actively in the market to buy.
“We haven’t actively been looking for a home to buy in the near future – that’s definitely not our goal – our goal is to have a home in a few years. We’re trying to start a family.” . . .
Patrick Gower wasn’t impressed either:
Labour’s campaign is listless, meandering and shambolic.
The media with him say it’s a bit of a shamble and have been reporting on it.
Reporters are doing stories about Cunliffe having curry for lunch and there are even whispers from the press pack that Cunliffe is taking naps, but I asked him straight up yesterday and he said “no”, no nana-naps, only the odd bit of kip while in the car (which isn’t a crime).
I took a look at Cunliffe’s campaign myself in Hobsonville yesterday.
Hobsonville quickly turned into campaign trail bizarro-world.
Cunliffe was out there to counter-attack on housing after Key trotted to the very same streets earlier in the week.
Cunliffe and housing spokesperson Phil Twyford re-announced the party’s Kiwbuild policy, saying Labour could build a $485,000 two-bedroom terraced house for $360,000 because of economies of scale.
But they didn’t have a house as an example, they were just standing on the street.
Twyford was saying there were heaps of examples of the $485,000 homes in Hobsonsville, but he didn’t know where they were and never got back to me with an address.
I can tell Twyford where one is – it’s just around the corner, a $450,000 two bedroom – I know because Key took us there on Monday.
Then they rolled out two first home buyers, Harrison and Jordy, who bagged National’s Homestart policy.
But under questioning they weren’t first home buyers at all, they weren’t even looking.
In fact they wouldn’t even buy a house under Labour’s policy.
Then it turned out that they were members of the EPMU, and they stopped answering questions when asked if they voted in Labour’s leadership campaign last election.
And despite the policy being around since David Shearer was leader, Labour still couldn’t come up with simple lines like when the first house will be built.
Then media weren’t allowed any more questions about the news of the day, Cunliffe had to “have a briefing” – for the uninitiated, this is unusual, as reporters usually just ask all the questions in one stand-up.
Cunliffe then went off on a “walkabout” which is what politicians do when campaigning, you shake a few hands and the cameras follow.
But there was nobody on the street, Cunliffe eventually turned around and came back again.
Then Cunliffe jumped in the Crown limousine which went for a cruise around the block using up taxpayer petrol so he could have his briefing. . .
The media stands around on the side of the street waiting. . .
Labour looks disorganised.
I will give Labour this free advice: Cunliffe won’t get to be Prime Minister by wandering aimlessly around a Hobsonsville cul-de-sac.
The party’s in a cul-de-sac, driven there by internal dissent, poor organisation and shambolic policy.
Labour chose the wrong couple and they’ve got the wrong policy:
New Zealanders can have no confidence in Labour’s housing policy when they can’t explain how it would work, when its housing spokespeople say different things and the announcement is a shambles, National’s Housing Spokesman Dr Nick Smith says.
“KiwiBuild is a joke because Labour has no idea how it would build 10,000 homes a year, cannot explain how they would pay for it and they still have not worked out who would be eligible for the homes,” Dr Smith says.
“Launching the policy in Hobsonville only served to highlight Labour’s previous failings.
“Labour in government announced a 1600-home development on this land in 2002, but by 2008 had no planning approved, no resource consents, no infrastructure built nor a single house constructed.
“If they couldn’t build 1600 houses in six years, how can they promise 10,000 a year now under KiwiBuild?
“Hobsonville is progressing at pace under National’s Special Housing Area, with 444 built and sold and another 350 to be completed this financial year.
“KiwiBuild keeps changing. In November 2012, it was 100,000 three-bedroom standalone homes costing under $300,000 each. In 2013, it had become two-bedroom townhouses for $300,000 and up to $550,000 for standalone four-bedroom houses. Today they are saying two-bedroom terraced houses for $360,000.
“Housing Spokesperson Phil Twyford says the houses will be paid for when built. Associate Housing Spokesperson Poto Williams says they will rented with a later first right to buy.
“Three years from now, under Labour’s numbers they would be lucky to deliver even 7000 homes.
“National’s policies address land supply, council development charges on sections, building materials costs, and help for first home buyers with a deposit and loan. This is the way forward to help more New Zealanders realise the dream of owning their own home.”
If Labour’s policy is this confusing it’s no wonder they couldn’t find anyone who could represent those who will benefit from it.
Contrasting with that is National’s policy which will help people help themselves.