There is a better way

You’ve got to feel sorry for Aucklanders.

Level 2 is bad enough for the rest of us with the impact on businesses and the uncertainty about public events and private functions.

How much worse if must be for Aucklanders at Level 3 – again.

It’s easy to say with hindsight, shifting the city out of Level 3 after only three days was a mistake.

There’s no point looking back to cast blame but we must learn from what’s gone wrong and look forward to how to do much better.

And National has a plan for that:

National is urging the Government to get on top of the latest Covid-19 outbreak in Auckland by adopting a five-point plan for managing community cases, National’s Covid-19 Response spokesperson Chris Bishop and Health spokesperson Dr Shane Reti say.

National’s five-point plan for managing community outbreaks:

  1. Introduce rapid antigen testing – nasal swab tests that return results in 15 minutes.
  2. Roll out high intensity, well-staffed testing stations across Papatoetoe and at every single location of interest
  3. Conduct higher intensity wastewater testing at suburb and sub-suburb levels in Papatoetoe
  4. Set aside enough vaccines for all border and port workers, then priority vaccinate South Auckland
  5. Increase monitoring of people who are required to self-isolate, including spot checks

Mr Bishop says New Zealand should follow the example of Taiwan where managed isolation at home comes with strict protocols, such as random phone calls and requests to confirm their location through a video call or supplying an image.

“The high trust approach we take to self-isolation in this country comes with risks, as we’ve seen over the past few days.

“New Zealanders have largely done a great job of following self-isolation advice but it’s unlikely we’ll ever have 100 per cent compliance, and it’s extremely frustrating when a small number of people don’t follow the rules.

“Monitoring of self-isolators should be ramped up to guarantee compliance. This means regular spot checks, and if no contact is made within 24 hours then police are involved.”

The Government also needs to roll out more staff across more testing sites to cut down waiting times and make it easier for people to visit a testing station, Mr Bishop says.

“Long queues and wait times will discourage people from getting tested. We need to fix this.”

Dr Reti says the Government should also introduce rapid antigen testing in New Zealand. These nasal swab tests provide results in 15 minutes and are common overseas.

“Rapid antigen testing would allow us to test large numbers of New Zealanders, quickly. Those who test positive would then have their results confirmed by a standard PCR test.

“These tests are common in other countries like the United States where there are FDA-approved home test kits for less than $15.

“They are especially good for giving quick answers and peace of mind to people who are showing symptoms of illness and want to know if they have Covid-19.”

Rapid antigen tests would be an added layer of testing alongside the standard nasal PCR tests already being done here. Our Government already considers them reliable enough to accept them as a pre-departure test for arrival into New Zealand.

Dr Reti says there should be daily wastewater inspection at ports, and at a more granular level in Papatoetoe than just the main interceptors.

The Government should also set aside enough vaccines for all border and port workers, then priority vaccinate South Auckland, starting with Papatoetoe High school followed by wider Papatoetoe in parallel with border and health workers.

“South Auckland presents an increased risk of transmission due to the density of its population and the number of border workers who reside there,” Dr Reti says.

We understand the need to prioritise other vulnerable groups, such as the elderly, for vaccination but stopping outbreaks at the source is also a form of protection of these groups.”

That we’ve been able to enjoy a summer as near to normal as it could be with the border closed looks more and more as if it was due to good luck than good management.

We can’t keep relying on luck.

None of the suggested improvements National is suggesting look difficult and whatever the cost it would be less expensive than shutting down Auckland and restricting what the rest of us can do, again.


6 Responses to There is a better way

  1. adamsmith1922 says:

    Reblogged this on The Inquiring Mind and commented:
    Rational thoughts, nah it will never catch on


  2. Andrei says:

    It’s easy to say with hindsight, shifting the city out of Level 3 after only three days was a mistake.

    Bah gumbug, putting Auckland into level 3 in the first place was a mistake.

    Is there anyone in Auclanad that is significantly ill from this virus?

    Is it feasible in the long term to keep this virus and its descendants out of New Zealand?

    What are the long term financial costs in trying to do so?

    Unquestionably the “law of unintended consequences” will come into play though how it will manifest itself at this point would be speculation.

    I do know there are anti lockdown protests in Dublin as people get fed up so civil disorder is possible

    And Chaos theory strongly suggests that artificially suppressing the normal spread of respiratory viruses will have a rebound effect when these methods are no longer viable


  3. Heather Adam says:

    Living in St Heliers, we observed the huge amount of preparation for the gathering of hundreds at the end of the Round the Bays run yesterday .. a run that, obviously, could not take place. We can only imagine the huge waste of food and drinks and this is just one example. All the restaurants in the area would also have been well stocked in anticipation of the ‘flow-on effect’. The problem was several kilometres away in South Auckland, almost zero chance of contact. Our country is already in deep debt … we can’t afford a shut-down every time a couple of suspects occur. Sensible management please !!


  4. Dave says:

    NZ, Labour just hasn’t got the planning and procedure in place to manage Covid at the borders, quarantine or local outbreaks and contact tracing.

    My real issue is the media who normally hold a government to account are doing and saying nothing, it’s like they have been bought off and silenced.

    Look to NSW with their world class contact tracing, they don’t just rely on calling and leaving a message, they visit anyone that cannot actually speak too within 12 hours. Look to the auto registering Covid tracing app in Aust, and the Bluetooth federal self registering contact app. Look to the ZERO contact in MIQ in Australia (except victoria). Most of these have been developed since March 16 last year and have been implemented to better manage COVID-19. But not in NZ, still using an app that was seriously outdated when it was realised, still allowing MIQ contact and poor adherence to the rules and process. Lazy lazy Labour.


  5. Heather Adam says:

    Dave … good comment. You suggest that the media may have been bought. I’m sure that your tongue was firmly in your cheek as you wrote it ! Most of us are assuming that over a hundred million thrown at them would be very effective. This government is very controlling, that’s for sure.


  6. Dave says:

    Yes, 100%, but they are also incredibly Lazy, there is not follow through and updates to policy, process or their pathetic Covid App. Sam Morgan from TradeMe fame offered to build a new one with similar features to the Aussie and Taiwan app, but Ardern and the MOH declined saying they were developing their own version. QLD is on to Version Three, their first version was still better than NZ still uses. The federal app also links anyone you are near (in bluetooth range of) for a few minutes, its automatic, nothing needs to be done by the user, all that is needed is the app is downloaded and bluetooth is turned on. Most companies make it compulsory for employees. Then their MIQ, friends have just been through, whilst friendly, it was not strict, with people stopping to chat in corridors, doors opened without masks or a care in the world.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: