Some more welcome than others

The move to alert level 1 takes us back to nearly as life was pre-Covid-19, except that border are closed, at least to some though not others:

With calving season about to kick off, calls are mounting for critical migrant workers to be allowed back into New Zealand.

Going into calving short-staffed isn’t how Waikato’s Duncan Scott wanted to begin the new milking season.

But like many dairy farmers around the country, Scott’s without key staff who are unable to return to New Zealand because of border restrictions prompted by the international Covid-19 pandemic. . . 

His herd manager has been on the farm for three years and can’t be replaced by someone inexperienced.

Scott said he understood the current drive to employ Kiwis and he had taken on people who were previously out of work because of the economic fallout of Covid-19.

“But you also need some experienced people to lead the new staff,” he said.

He gave an analogy of what it might be like replacing the herd manager with an inexperienced person.

“If you can imagine someone turning up to Waikato Hospital to give birth and finding the midwife is an airline pilot who has been out of work for the past three weeks.

“That’s the situation we are in and that’s why we need these guys (migrant workers) back in the country.” . . 

Federated Farmers immigration and labour spokesperson Chris Lewis also farms near the Scott family in the Pukeatua district in the Waikato.

He is aware of the labour shortage but said it appeared only movie stars were allowed in the country, referring to the crew of the Avatar sequel. . .

Experienced dairy staff with work visas aren’t allowed in, but relatives of film crew are:

Ten of the 200 high-value foreigners – such as the Avatar film crew – allowed entry into New Zealand during the border restrictions were relatives of the workers.

The news comes as work visa holders and their families – already settled in New Zealand but out of the country when the border closed in March – clamour for permission to return.

The immigration industry has added its voice, saying urgent applications from New Zealand employers for vital overseas staff are languishing in a ‘deep dark hole’.

The government has faced criticism for the opaque process behind the exemptions, including initially that they even existed. . . 

Getting to level 1 and having no active cases of Covid-19 has come at a very high economic and social cost.

We can’t afford to undo the gains with lax border restrictions.

But providing people who come in agree to managed isolation and, where needed, quarrantine at their own expense people with work visas, family of residents and citizens and anyone else who will make a positive contribution to the economy, for example foreign students, should be allowed in.

Like several other government policies current border restrictions are arbitrary and unfair, making some people more welcome than others with no fair grounds for discriminating.

5 Responses to Some more welcome than others

  1. Andrei says:

    It all goes to show how out of touch with reality the Wellingtonian mandarins really are.

    And what they value and what they don’t .

    This, perhaps, has been the biggest outbreak of mass hysteria in history led by a totally irresponsible mass media and a weak political class.


  2. Roj Blake says:

    This is not a failure of government, it is a failure of Capitalism. It is the drive to maximise profits at the expense of training the next generation of dairy workers.

    It is “cheaper” to import labour trained elsewhere at someone else’s cost than it is to train locals. Until the costs come home to roost because the cheap import is no longer available and there is no pool of trained locals to do the job.


  3. Andrei says:

    Sorry Roj – the “locals” are not for the most part not interested in agricultural work, in regions far removed from the night life of the city, which requires an early bed, early to rise ethos and requires hard physical labour in often inclement conditions.


  4. Roj Blake says:

    Andrei, a double negative makes a positive, and I agree with you, there are a number of locals who would be interested in a career in dairying, but that is not being offered to them.

    But, I am sure, with all your extensive dairying experience, you are capable of speaking for all dairy farmers.


  5. adamsmith1922 says:

    Reblogged this on The Inquiring Mind.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: