Experience not necessary?

Young Farmers once ran a campaign to recruit members with the line you don’t have to be one to be one.

It came to mind again when I looked at Labour’s new line-up.

David Farrar analysed the new front bench and found half of the members are from Wellington, there’s not a single one from provincial New Zealand and none at all from Christchurch nor any from anywhere else in the South Island.

Where spokespeople come from shouldn’t affect their ability to get to grips with their portfolios but the dearth of talent outside Wellington and Auckland will handicap the attempt to reconnect with the whole country.

Of more relevance to their ability to develop policy is talent and they are all on a one-year trial to determine whether they are up to the challenge facing them.

Some have bigger challenges than others.

Having been involved in sectors relevant to their portfolios in their lives before parliament isn’t a prerequisite for spokespeople or ministers.

There are some areas when a fresh approach might even be an advantage. There are others where some prior knowledge and understanding would be helpful.

The smaller your caucus and the thinner on talent it is the more difficult it is to match MPs with portfolios in which they have relevant experience. The task Andrew Little obviously faced in allocating positions reinforces the dire straits in which the election and the lack of renewal left the parliamentary wing of the party.

The glaring gap in the CVs of too many in the line-up is private sector experience, among them is the new finance spokesman Grant Robertson.

Several of the policies Labour promoted before the last election showed a party far more interested in spending other people’s money than is good for the economy and the wealth creation and jobs which depend on it.

A finance spokesman with real life experience in the private sector and who has risked his own capital might be more predisposed to a more disciplined approach to policy development than one who hasn’t.



2 Responses to Experience not necessary?

  1. Gravedodger says:

    Excellent summary and a very revealing statement in the light of the concerted campaign around the decline of the provinces and the crisis in manufacturing that had one little Andy Little in the van at all times.

  2. Tony Stuart says:

    Very well said Ele. The one glaring area of skill deficit within the Labour caucus seems to be in matters legal. Jacinda Ardern has a BA in Communications, and yet has been allocated the Justice portfolio, which is normally given to someone with a legal background. She will face a formidable opponent in Amy Adams, and will need someone close to her with significant legal experience to keep her on top of a very important portfolio.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: