Lowering the tone

Debate in parliament can be robust, it can also be personal and in the past week there’s been a lowering of the tone with a descent into nastiness:

NZ First leader Winston Peters is known for his expensive suits but he triggered a Savile row of a different nature when he turned on ex-NZ First MP Brendan Horan this week. To say there is bad blood between the two is an insult to leukemia. The loathing runs deeper than the Marianas Trench, as wide as the mouth of the Amazon.

But to do as Peters did, and to describe Horan as “the Jimmy Savile of NZ politics”  – and to do so not once but twice in what was clearly a calculated insult – takes it to a whole new level. Savile, the deceased British “celebrity” who sexually preyed on young, often handicapped, girls, is the nuclear option of insults. It all looked a bit desperate. You cannot make such a comment without backing it up with some evidence.

Yet Peters not only failed to do so, but failed to front in Parliament the following day, when Horan had signalled he would reveal his own deep scandal about NZ First.

It left the rest of the NZ First MPs – who tend to resemble a bunch of ageing Social Creditors with anger management issues at the best of times – making a shambles of trying to use Parliament’s standing orders to block their former colleague.

In the end, Horan’s revelations Peters was using the leader’s budget for electioneering and campaigning expenses, namely software and staff, proved something of a damp squib. It is still far from clear NZ First is doing anything wrong with its Parliamentary funding, although no doubt the party does – like all the others – push it right up to the edge of the rules. . .

New Zealand wasn’t the only party guilty of lowering the tone:

Back in February, Trans-Tasman (14/1933) called attention to what it saw as a “crusty, even nasty, undertone” in political debate. This week the tone was definitely nasty, and it wasn’t an undertone. Winston Peters was slugging it out with his onetime colleague, now independent MP, Brendan Horan labelling him the “Jimmy Savile of NZ politics.” Judging by the sycophantic responses from other NZ First MPs, it was a rehearsed line to put down Horan, who had been trying to table NZ First board meeting minutes, telling Parliament they “point to improper use of taxpayer money.” Just as unpleasant was the tweet from Green MP Jan Logie – “John Key says Bill English has produced as many Budgets as children. Begs the question who he has f&%d to produce it.” Logie subsequently apologised for the comment, but it showed how far current Green MPs have moved from the high standards of former leaders the late Rod Donald and Jeanette Fitzsimons. . .

It’s not only far from the standards of the past, it’s a long way from the current code of conduct for Green MPs and the lowering of tone has resulted in a call for MPs to mind their manners:

Prime Minister John Key is warning MPs to behave following what he describes as “a nasty streak” running through Parliament. . . 

Mr Key said on Thursday that politicians risk offending the public with nasty behaviour or mindless tweets.

“Political parties actually need to think about that a little bit. We’re seeing tweets that I think have been wholly inappropriate, we’ve seen all sorts of allegations been made that are unfounded.

“It’s one thing to have parliamentary privilege – it’s quite another thing to actually say those things, because actually they do have repercussions, they do send ripples through the community.”

Mr Key said a tweet is no different from a media statement.

The sort of nastiness that’s been exhibited in the past week is what puts a lot of people off politics.

It adds to the negative view many have of politicians.

And it puts the focus on the petty and personal instead of the principles and policies which really matter.

5 Responses to Lowering the tone

  1. RBG says:

    John Key is comfortable about assisting the US killing people without trial by drones in countries that are not at war, but he is upset about nasty language. FFS GET A GRIP!

  2. JC says:

    Drone strikes are not illegal. UN resolutions say countries suppressing suspected terrorists using drones must have due regard for human rights of civilians and maintain “proportionality”.


    And our own Terrorism Suppression Act 2002 authorises actions taken outside of NZ. This Act of course was enacted on instruction by the UN after 9/11.


  3. Andrei says:

    countries suppressing suspected terrorists using drones must have due regard for human rights of civilians and maintain “proportionality”

    Do you think she is pretty JC? Well do you?

    Pray do tell?

    Drones are used by cowardly, bullies – operated from nice, secure air conditioned rooms located on a continent far away from where they deal death to the poor in third world countries or have no way of defending themselves against them.

    “Terrorists” are who our overlords say they are and who are we to reason why?

  4. Gravedodger says:

    That the political reporters have not pursued the reference to the TWO Jimmy Saville comments directed at Horan says it all really about the gutless hero worship easy copy relationship between the now seriously declining Cult leader and their own increasing irrelevance.
    If there is any slight relevance to such a disgusting unchallenged bit of Peters normal behavior he should be called to account for it

    What the US does in its response to employing drones to diminish the threat to world security is of seriously minimal connect to this thread but then TROLLS don’t have much truck with such matters.

    It was not nasty language you Muppet, it was the declining standards and the Nats are a part of that hence Joyce’s embarrassing departure yesterday.

  5. Andrei says:

    Who cares if it was trolling GD

    Watching parliament is no different to watching “Australia’s biggest loser” – they are both circuses designed to distract us from what our real masters are up to.

    Anyway we will have our farcical election later this year, with its foregone conclusions and another Parliament with a few new clowns will emerge to keep you amused.

    And you will continue to believe you have a say

    You poor deluded man!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: