Prove it

Act leader Jamie White is challenging David Cunliffe to prove he’d be better at investing money than the private sector.

The Labour Party has announced a return to “industrial policy”. If elected, they will decide which businesses and sectors of the economy will deliver the highest returns and promote them in various ways – most obviously, by subsidising them with taxpayers’ money.

This policy effectively replaces the decisions of private investors with the decisions of Labour Party politicians. It would be a foolish policy if Labour Party politicians were not better investors than the private investors they will replace.

So, before asking people to vote for the policy, shouldn’t David Cunliffe prove that he and his colleagues really are better investors than those who do it professionally?

He could do this easily. Mr Cunliffe could set up a small investment fund – $5,000 would suffice to get started – and trade it in the months before the election. Since he claims to know better than private investors which businesses will give the best returns, his fund should massively outperform the NZX 50 and other stock market indices. . .

Mr Cunliffe talks a good game when it comes to investing. And he plans to put your money where his mouth is. But before anyone goes along with him, they should insist that he puts his own money where his mouth is.

So I challenge Mr Cunliffe. Trade the stock market in the months before the election. Publish your trades as you make them and explain how you arrived at your supposed knowledge of which investments are best. By the election we will be able to see if you really do know what you claim to.

If you won’t accept the challenge, then withdraw your proposal to use taxpayers’ money to invest in the businesses that take your fancy.

A defining feature of the National-led government since 2008 is a respect for public money because they understand it’s other people’s.

That has yet to penetrate the we-know-better fog which envelopes the left, all of whom are concentrating on how they’ll divide the national pie rather than working on how to make it bigger.

2 Responses to Prove it

  1. Angry Tory says:

    A defining feature of the National-led government since 2008 is a respect for public money because they understand it’s other people’s.

    Oh what rubbish. Borrowing a BILLION dollars every month since 2008.

    3.2 BILLION Flushed away to SCF.

    MILLIONS more on the Smelter unions, the casino unions, and now the teacher unions!

    and FIFTY billion flushed away every year on “benefits”, “welfare’, “health” and ‘education” – all of it “other peoples’ money”.

    Like

  2. Adolf Fiinkensein says:

    You’d better see a vet about all that excess bile.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: