Opponents to the partial sale of state assets complain about the loss of dividends, they forget about the costs.
Trans Tasman points out the risks of state ownership:
. . .there is a harsh reality to be faced, not only with Solid Energy (what’s a Govt trying to do in owning coal mines?) but with other state-owned entities whose profitability has shrunk: think of TVNZ, NZ Post, Kordia. Not surprisingly, Solid Energy’s troubles have thrown into relief how the Govt’s balance sheet, already structurally weak, can be pushed into dangerous territory by businesses where all the risks have to be shouldered by the taxpayer.
Opponents to the sales complain that the government will lose dividend income when up to 49% of shares in an SOE are sold.
They forget the risks and costs of ownership which ultimately fall on the taxpayer.
I’d rather have my taxes pay for core government responsibilities like defence, police, infrastructure, health and welfare than investment in areas best left to the private sector.