Next election already too close

The exact make-up of the new government has yet to be confirmed but the next election already seems too close.

The Herald opines that it’s time to consider a four-year term and I agree.

It takes months for a new government and its ministers to get up to speed which leaves a little more than a year for progress before everything slows down in election year and finally stops altogether during the campaign.

The uncertainty isn’t good for business:

Massey’s senior finance lecturer Dr Alexander Molchanov was part of a team that studied stock market volatility across 50 countries in the six-month lead up to an election and in the year after.

They found countries that hold national elections have more volatile economies than autocracies because investors and businesses are put off by the risks associated with political uncertainty.

The study also revealed that markets do not always settle down the year after an election.

“Export-oriented industries in particular, such as we have in New Zealand, show higher volatility when political risks are high,” says Dr Molchanov.

 That shouldn’t be construed as an argument for no elections but it’s not only business which would benefit from a longer cycle.

A man employed in the social service sector who works with ministries and politicians told me he was frustrated by three yearly elections because just as everyone was getting up to speed the campaign and post-election changes interrupted them.

A slightly longer cycle would help the economy and save money.

It costs millions of dollars to run an election. Adding an extra year to the cycle would mean we’d have to pay for three elections in 12 years rather than four.

A slightly longer cycle would reduce the costs for and demands on volunteers too. Julie at the Hand Mirror gives an insiders’ view on what it’s like to have a candidate in the family and supporters also work very hard during a campaign.

One reason for a shorter term is the constraint it places on governments when we don’t have an upper house. But the election shows that with MMP it would be difficult, almost impossible, for a single party to gain an outright majority.

The consitutional review panel is considering the parliamentary term. The recommendations won’t be binding and if it went to a referendum the public’s disdain for politicians might well find the option of a four-year term would lose.

That would be a pity. Government would be more efficient and slightly less expensive with a four term year and the country would benefit from a slightly longer gap between the interruptions imposed on it by elections.

2 Responses to Next election already too close

  1. Gravedodger says:

    If it is accepted that MMP delivers a fairer and therefore more stable government and that Government will in nearly every case be subject to a withdrawing of Confidence and Supply, we should have been given that basic constitutional question as part of the recent referendum allied to a fixed term also.
    Some say that would have given the Clark government 12 years, I say it would have ended at 8 and we wouldn’t be holding Cullen’s wet dream train set at more than twice what it should have cost.

    The 3 year cycle is too compressed for good governance and with the clear liklyhood of coalitions being required to get the votes necessary for C & S which should also be the only reason to early termination of a “fixed” term parliament and if an early election is called due to losing C & S then reversion to the fixed term occur as scheduled. Any short interim government be “managed” by the Govenor General with whatever it takes to limp to the next scheduled quadrennial election.

    The collective abilities of the voters to punish any politician stupid enough to game the system is reliable enough imo.


  2. homepaddock says:

    GD – I second your proposition for a fixed four-year term.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: