Labouring the list

Party lists are of great importance to the people on them.

That’s understandable for anyone not standing in an electorate, or standing with little or no chance of winning. But even those with safe seats often want a high place for ego’s sake if nothing else.

Those ranking the list labour over them trying to present a line-up which will appeal to voters without disrupting caucus and upsetting non-MP candidates which can be mutually exclusive goals.

But does anyone else, even political tragics, really pay much attention to them?

The lists are made public once they’ve been sorted but unless there is someone who is well known I’d be very surprised if many voters know, or care, about who is on them and in which order.

The only time after an election a list matters is if a list MP jumps or is pushed from parliament when the next person on the list is invited to take his or her place.

Sometimes,  a party has second thoughts about the ranking as Keeping Stock reminds us the Green Party did  when co-leader Russel Norman leapfrogged Catherine Delahunty and Mike Ward to get into parliament before the last election.

When the Labour list was ranked in 2008 the importance of not upsetting sitting MPs must have had at least some bearing but that is now causing them problems.  The next person on the list is former MP Judith Tizard who must be offered the place vacated by Darren Hughes. If she turns it down it’s offered to Mark Burton, Mahara Okeroa, Martin Gallagher and Dave Hereora, all former MPs who, Labour president Andrew Little told Mary Wilson on Checkpoint, will not be on this year’s list.

The next one on the list is Louisa Wall another former MP but one who is standing again.

It is possible that the next five people on Labour’s list won’t want to disrupt their lives to return to parliament for a few months. But, has anyone asked them if they’d like to return for longer? The Labour list has yet to be ranked so if one of the five made the sacrifice they could be offered a place which has the potential to keep them in parliament for the next term.

But from what Little said last night, that isn’t a consideration. Instead it looks like five people will be expected to not take the place which they are entitled to by the law giving a whole new meaning to the term labouring (or should that be Labouring?) the list.

UPDATE: Kiwiblog notes that the five could-be MPs would be turning down 11 months salary if they decline the chance to return to parliament.

5 Responses to Labouring the list

  1. pdm says:

    “It is possible that the next five people on Labour’s list won’t want to disrupt their lives to return to parliament for a few months”.

    I doubt the above applies to Judith Tizard. I mean what else does she do!!

    Like

  2. Inventory2 says:

    Quite so Ele, and well said. This is a gross abuse of the democratic process by Labour, and it is one for which they should be held accountable – by the voters.

    Like

  3. Nominations for Labour list spots closed a while ago. And the process is already well advanced.

    Like

  4. homepaddock says:

    I2 – I suspect few voters will know and most of them will have forgotten by November.

    Graeme – does the party constitution not allow for late nomincations to cover something like this?

    Like

  5. Inventory2 says:

    It may all be academic anyway. Newstalk ZB is reporting that Judith Tizard has told Barry Soper that she has got unfinished business in the form of not having the opportunity to deliver a valedictory speech. He was of the impression that she intends to take up the list seat which is legally hers both under electoral law and the Labour Party’s constitution. I doubt that she has needed any help from afar in reaching a personal decision, and good on her!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: