Bad bag charge gets worse

North Island New Worlds dropped the 5 cent charge on plastic bags after customers voted with their feet and went to other supermarkets.

We were less bolshie in the south but obviously there were complaints from more than the small group of customers which Foodstuffs general manager said has now prompted the company to drop the charge in South Island New World’s too.

However, the charge will remain in Pak’N Save and Four Square supermarkets because they had not experienced the same negative feedback.

I’ve been using reusable bags most of the time for several years but the principle of being charged more than the plastic bags cost so the company could donate money to charity annoyed me.

Now it’s not just the principle that I”m tetchy about, it’s the fact that they’ve removed it from some supermarkets but not all of them.

Groceries at Four Square stores are usually more expensive than at other supermarkets because they tend to be the smaller neighbourhood or rural stores which don’t usually have competitors near by.

In town many of the people who use them are likely to be unable to get to bigger supermarkets easily, perhaps because they’re elderly or don’t have a car.

In the country the cost of going further to another supermarket would be greater than savings to be made from the lower prices.

If there’s one positive thing about the bag charge debacle, it’s that it shows the positive power of competition. Obviously New World supermarkets have competition and enough customers changed to competitors to force Foodstuffs to drop the bag charge there.

Having done that it looks self-serving to continue the charge in Four Square stores just because most of their customers can’t easily take their custom elsewhere.

3 Responses to Bad bag charge gets worse

  1. JC says:

    New World is smaller, doesn’t have shelves that tower over you and is more personable, so it attracts the elderly and disabled.
    To that demographic, plastic bags are a boon for wrapping food scraps and general parceling of rubbish and breaking up food into smaller amounts for freezing.

    Such bagging up also reduces smell, is less enticing for dogs when the rubbish bags are out on the street etc, so removing the plastic bags changes the way they’ve handled their groceries for years.

    Whilst we often had an excessive number of bags around we found our children snapped them up when the grandchildren arrived.. you know why 🙂



  2. Neil says:

    I complained every time I visited the local NW supermarket to the person keeping an eye on the self service check outs.
    What needs to be stated over and over again, was that the charge for plastic bags was built into the existing charges. This wasn’t costing NW a cent !
    How noble they were!. Bugger the customers ! They were assuming that South Islanders wouldn’t complain about the charge. It wasn’t the charge but the principle behind it.


  3. lilacsigil says:

    My town has been plastic bag free for years now, and it’s great. But everyone has to do it, or it won’t work. You can use a reusable bag, get a free recycled cardboard box at the supermarket, or pay cost price (5c) for a paper bag. And for people that complain about not having plastic bags (as everyone here did before it was implemented), you do still get vegie bags and meat bags, so we use and re-use those quite happily.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: