Fencing us in

Palmerston North coroner Tim Scott has called for farmers and the Labour Department to lobby government to make fencing compulsory for all farm houses.

Mr Scott said sharemilking agreements should make it mandatory for houses occupied by sharemilkers and their families to be adequately fenced.

He wanted his decision referred to the Labour Department’s Occupational Health and Safety Unit, Federated Farmers, and an appropriate farm worker union, the Dominion Post reported.

Legislation would be needed to make fencing mandatory.

Mr Scott said the legislation could be similar to the Fencing of Swimming Pools Act, which promotes child safety by requiring the fencing of some pools.

This follows the death of a three year old who died after she and her brother fell into an effluent pond about 75 metres from their house. The house wasn’t fenced, there was a stock fence between the house and the pond.

The children’s parents, who were sharemilkers, had asked the farm owner to fence the house. He had bought fencing materials but asked the child’s father to wait until the section was levelled before building the fence.

This is a tragedy made worse because of the if onlys:  if only the fence had been built, if only the pond had been fenced, if only the children hadn’t been playing outside . . .

The coroner is quite clear in his findings that the parents were not to blame.

The sharemilking agreement had a clause which said the property would be fenced but it was in the fine print of a standard contract – 119 of 161 clauses on 37 pages.

He recommends that share milking agreements make it mandatory for all houses occupied by sharemilkers and their families be adequately fenced and that this clause be highlighted.

He goes on to recommend that all farm houses should be securely fenced.

But how practical is that and if farm hosues are to be childproof why not every home?

Farms are full of dangers but is an effluent pond nearly 100 metres from a house in the country any more dangerous than a busy road right outside one in town?

And how do you make a whole property completely childproof?

Friends had a deer fence round their house and the children learned to climb it. Other friends had their gate fastened so securely that visiting adults couldn’t get in but their three year old son managed to get out.

6 Responses to Fencing us in

  1. Adolf Fiinkensein says:

    Well HP, reality is that farms are places of business and are dangerous places for kids. It seems to me that a fence around a house is an absolute minimum. I don’t know of too many homes in the city where young children have ready and easy access to the road.


  2. homepaddock says:

    Adolf, you’re right that farms are work places with many dangers. But not all farm houses have children and town houses without children don’t necessarily have fences.


  3. Pique Oil says:

    The mantra for H&S is Identify,eliminate,Isolate,minimise and monitor.
    From the report I read the hazard had been identified and then for various reasons nothing was done.
    Elimination is not possible so it becomes a matter of isolation.
    Life is never perfectly safe and nothing can make it so, but on the evidence I have read this incident was preventable.


  4. it’s so sad to hear. people often overlook them but fences save a bunch of lives.


  5. Ed Snack says:

    Adolf, are you serious ? I would guess that probably 80% of urban houses have no permanent gates on every means of egress from their properties to a road. No house I have ever owned or lived has had that, and that’s a fair few over the years. A quick survey in my current street, first 12 houses down the same side (other side is fields), none are fully fenced and gated.

    Recall in this case, the effluent pond was fenced off from the house, those children had to negotiate that fence, how would another fence have made any difference ? The children climbed or got through one fence, they would, had they wished, have done exactly the same to another. This is another coroner who desperately needs a reality implant.

    I would also have thought that it was uncommon for a house not to be fenced, most people don’t want stock right next to a house anyway, it gets hard to leave doors open for a start.


  6. […] scrubone 12:43 pm Homepaddock blogs on the recommendation that all farm houses be fenced, after the tragic death of a child. […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: