What’s wrong with the RMA?


The RMA is supposed to protect the environment but it’s used to stifle competition:

Supermarket giant Progressive Enterprises is appealing an Environment Court decision to allow rival Foodstuffs to open a supermarket on Auckland’s North Shore.

I know nothing about the merits of Foodstuffs’ case but it appears the opposition has nothing to do with the environment and we had a similar problem, on a much smaller scale, with a consent application.

We wanted to take water from the Kakanui River. Our application was for a B water right which meant we could only pump water from the river when it was at high flows and we’d have to stop before any other irrigators so would have no impact on their takes.

We tried to go non-notified and got sign-off from DOC, Fish & Game and the local Iwi. This is obviously quite rare because one of the Regional Council staff suggested we frame the letters. However, existing irrigators opposed the application so we had to notify it and then the Kakanui Ratepayers and Residents Association opposed us too.

We went to a hearing, were granted consent,  but the KRRA appealed it.

Two years, and at least $20,000 later in direct costs plus more in lost income when we had to dry cows off early because we ran out of water for irrigation, their lawyer finally told them they didn’t have a case and they gave up.

5 Responses to What’s wrong with the RMA?

  1. rayinnz says:

    I cannot understand why costs are not ordered against the plaintifs when after wasting all that time (and money) they drop their case
    That might stop the more silly NIMBY cases for a start


  2. pmofnz says:

    Unfortunately I suspect HP has to live in that same community as the Ratepayers Assn.


  3. Spam says:

    Mitre 10 used the RMA to keep Bunnings out of Nelson for a long time, too.


  4. homepaddock says:

    Ray – it was an incorporated society and had almost no funds. If we’d gone for costs they’d just have disolved the society.


  5. […] had a very expensive experience  with a vexatious objection when we applied for consent to take water fromt he Kakanui […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: