Can’t argue about quality

The ODT editorial sums up the issue of Fonterra’s handling of the poisoned milk in China:

Quality control where food products are concerned is simply unarguable and the damage done for the lack of it to Fonterra’s good name by this tragic event suggests the company needs to have taken, and to continue to take, a great deal more direct interest in such partnerships.

Fonterra CEO  Andrew Ferrier is right that the poisoning was sabotage and that the problem spread far wider than his company. But there were concerns about Chinese food safety standards so Fonterra should have been far more cautious and rigorous about quality control with Sanlu in which it has a 43% stake.

If it couldn’t have prevented the problem it should have gone public far sooner after it was recognised. If they weren’t able to do that in China they could have done it here so that in spite of the repressive controls on media there the word would have got out.

Public health ought to have been their first priority and if they hadn’t wanted to risk business relationships in China by doing it openly they could have done it quietly then put the blame on our media. But they should have done it as soon as possible after concerns were raised.

Whether that would have saved any babies’ lives and lessened the severity of or prevented illness in others is a moot point. But there would have been no hesitation about a public recall of contaminated infant milk formula here and there shouldn’t have been there.

The only way Fonterra, or any other New Zealand company which goes in to business overseas, can safeguard its reputation, is to ensure that it has the same safety standards and concern for public health there as it does here.

Dig N Stir and Macdoctor have related posts.

3 Responses to Can’t argue about quality

  1. Kiss of X says:

    They knew about it before the Olympics. Who would have thought internet censorship and empty protest parks were not the real news of the day? Compared to poisoning babies wholesale.

    Not good enough, world.


  2. Mr Dennis says:

    The other thing Fonterra needs to ensure is that its products are being marketed honestly in China. Although illegal, it appears that infant formula is often marketed over there as better than breastmilk, which is very dishonest and damaging. This could well be the reason for such widespread formula use in the first place, in a country that traditionally has been strong on breastfeeding. If Fonterra wants to preserve its reputation internationally it needs to look at this carefully, and not just trust the “official” information but actually independently look at how it is marketed in practice.


  3. eucalyptusjandals says:

    I was wondering whether formula was being marketed as preferable to breastmilk. It’s really shocking. Poor babies.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: