Bill English has referred to MMP as working with people you don’t like to implement policies you don’t agree with.
That’s the reality of the system and while I would like John Key and National to rip into Winston Peters and say they won’t have him in a National-led government, I understand that they are holding back in case election results require them to work with him and New Zealand First.
If National doesn’t get a majority on election day, and even though the polls have been pointing to that possiblity it’s improbable, they’re going to need at least one colation partner. If they’re faced with the choice of dealing with Peters and his party or another three years in opposition they’re very unlikely to choose the latter.
Some people reckon parties should be quite clear about who they are prepared to work with before the election but as we saw in 2005 results can change intentions. Labour and the Greens made the most of photo opporutnities between their leaders during the campaign to promote a Labour Green coaltion. But when the Greens couldn’t deliver the numbers after the election Helen Clark had to turn her back on them and deal with New Zealand First and United Future.
That’s politics under MMP and that’s why Labour and National have to leave the door ever so slightly open for Peters.
But while the politicians won’t shut the door in his face the people can slam it. If Peters doesn’t win Tauranga and NZ First gets less than 5% of the party vote then neither he nor his party will be in the next parliament.
The make up of the next parliament and government isn’t up to politicians it’s up to voters.

100% on the money.
LikeLike
If you will allow me the liberty of a link, Rudman’s article in the Herald today is a far more substantive attack on Peters.
LikeLike
Good post HP – in reality, if you are motivated to get rid of the Clark-led Labour government, a party vote for National is the safest option. Although this election is an MMP election, it’s almost a case of going back to the future, and treating it as a two-horse race. Centre-right voters is Ohariu-Belmont and Epsom can do National a favour by returning the sitting MP’s to Parliament with their electorate vote. I hope that NZ First is annihilated come November, but I worry about the influence that the small number of people who support Winston can impart.
LikeLike
The people who support Peters won’t be worried about the issues surrounding these donations. The people who are worried about it weren’t going to vote for him anyway. It’s hard to see him losing much support over this. On the other hand, his party has been increasingly marginal as its supporters have aged and died – the fading remnants of ‘Rob’s Mob’.
LikeLike