Happy birthday Andy Taylor – 49 today.
Electoral Finance law reform announced
February 16, 2010Justice Minister Simon Power has announced the government’s reform package for electoral finance law.
He said:
”The package comes after extended consultation with all parliamentary parties and the public.
“As a result, Cabinet has decided to progress reforms only where there is broad public and political support.
“If we are to have a system which is fair, workable, enduring, and in place before the 2011 election, broad consensus is essential.”
Proposal in the package include:
- Require disclosure of the total amount of donations that parties receive in bands.
- Increase the amount of money that parties and candidates can spend on election campaigning at the rate of inflation for each general election.
- Require people who spend more than $12,000 on parallel campaigning to register with the Electoral Commission. The register will be publicly available to ensure openness and transparency concerning the identities of parallel campaigners.
- Bring more certainty to what counts as ‘election advertising’ by modernising the definition and requiring the Electoral Commission to issue guidance and advisory opinions about election advertisements.
- Clarify the relationship between the Electoral Act 1993 and Parliamentary Service legislation.
- Maintain the regulated campaign period to be three months before polling day.
The acknowledgement that broad consensus is necessary is a very good start. One of the many problems with the mess Labour made of electoral finance changes was bulldozing them through without wide support.
Increasing the amount which parties and candidates can spend with inflation is sensible.
So is bringing more certainty to what counts as election advertising and requiring the Electoral Commission to issue guidance and advisory opinions. Confusion about what was permitted and what wasn’t and fear of getting it wrong restrained free expression before the last election.
Returning the regulated period to three months before polling day rather than from January 1 of an election year is also a good move. Although I’d add, or from the announcement of the election if that is less than three months from polling day.
Related to that is clarifying the relationship between the Electoral Act and parliamentary Service legislation – we must not have a repeat of the pledge card and other rorts where parties and MPs campaigned with public money.
More information ont he review is available at the Justice Ministry.
UPDATE: Kiwiblog says consensus is the right way to approach the issue reform but it kills most meaningful electoral finance reform.
Don’t let the numbers get in the way of a campaign
February 16, 2010The pro MMP poster at No Right Turn says I’d rather live in a democracy with 120 MPs than a dictatorship with 99.
I’ll ignore the debate on whether MMP really is any more democratic than other electoral systems and stick with the numbers.
If we still had FPP we wouldn’t yet have 120 MPs but we’d have more than 99 unless the formula for setting electoral boundaries had changed.
The number of electorate seats keeps increasing under MMP and they would have under FPP too.
The number of South Island seats was fixed under FPP and still is with MMP. Under both systems the South Island population is divided by that fixed number of seats and that figure is used to determine how many people will be in each electorate in both islands, plus or minus 5%.
The North Island population grows faster than that of the South so every six years when electorate boundaries are calculated we get another seat or two.
Had we still had FPP we’d be approaching 110 MPs.
This formula is why MMP will eventually stop working as it’s intended to. Each time an electorate seat is added a list seat is subtracted. We started with 65 electorate seats (60 general and 5 Maori) and 55 list seats in 1996. Now there are 70 electorate and 52 list seats (an overhang of two).
Unless there’s an increase in the total number of seats in parliament we’ll get to a stage where the number of list seats is so small proportionality will be lost.
The alternative is to reduce the number of South Island electorates but the big rural electorates in both islands already cover far too big an area.
Whatever the referendum result, there will have to be changes eventually and the price of maintaining proportionality might be more MPs – electorate and list.
Monday’s quiz
February 15, 20101. What was the origin of the term proof in relation to alcohol content?
2. What does stick to one’s last mean?
3. What are the two smallest countries, by area, in the world?
4. Who said, “New Zealand is a country of thirty thousand million sheep, three million of whom think they are human.”
5. Who is New Zealand’s Minister of Internal Affairs?
Mining doesn’t have to be a dirty word
February 15, 2010Moonlight sounds romantic but there wasn’t much romance in the dry, barren East Otago hills where farmers struggled from drought to drought.
There’s still no romance there, but since the area was opened up for gold mining there’s been plenty of life. Conditions on consents are safeguarding the environment and ensure that the land is left in a better state than it was before the mining started.
They’ve proved that mining doesn’t have to be a dirty word and there is no reason the same thing couldn’t happen in a few selected areas of the conservation estate with low conservation values.
When someone says National Park, most of us think of beautiful bush, glorious mountains and pristine water ways. But it’s not all like that.
Some of it’s like this:
There’s some native scrub and exotic weeds; it’s home to wild rabbits, hares, pigs and deer; it’s no where near tourist trails and it borders private land.
If there were minerals of value under land like this, they could be extracted with minimum disruption to the neighbours. One of the conditions imposed on the mining company could be that the land is planted in natives when the mining is finished.
This would provide jobs and income and leave the land in a better condition than it is now.
What’s the problem with that?
February 15 in history
February 15, 2010On February 15:
509 Khosrau II is crowned king of Persia
1564 Galileo Galilei, Italian astronomer and physicist, was born.
1637 – Ferdinand III becomes Holy Roman Emperor.
1804 – Serbian revolution started.
1805 – Harmony Society was officially formed.
The Harmony Society church in Old Economy Village, Pennsylvania.
1812 Charles Lewis Tiffany, American jeweller, was born.
1820 Susan B. Anthony, American suffragist, was born.
![]() |
1835 – The first constitutional law in modern Serbia was adopted.
1852 – Great Ormond St Hospital for Sick Children, London, admitted its first patient.
1874 Sir Ernest Shackleton, Irish Antarctic explorer, was born.
1877 Louis Renault, French automobile executive, was born.
1879 American President Rutherford B. Hayes signed a bill allowing female attorneys to argue cases before the Supreme Court of the United States.
1882 The first shipment of frozen meat left New Zealand.

1891 AIK was founded at Biblioteksgatan 8 in Stockholm by Isidor Behrens.
1898 – Spanish-American War: The USS Maine exploded and sank in Havana harbour, killing more than 260.
1906 – The British Labour Party was formed.
1909 Miep Gies, Dutch biographer of Anne Frank, was born.
![]() |
|
1909 The Flores Theatre fire in Acapulco, 250 died.
1942 The Fall of Singapore. Following an assault by Japanese forces, British General Arthur Percival surrendered. About 80,000 Indian, United Kingdom and Australian soldiers become prisoners of war, the largest surrender of British-led military personnel in history. The Sook Ching massacre began.
Lt Gen. Arthur Percival, led by a Japanese officer, walks under a flag of truce to negotiate the capitulation of Allied forces in Singapore, on 15 February 1942.
1944 The assault on Monte Cassino, started.
Ruins of Cassino town after the battle
1944 Mick Avory, British drummer (The Kinks), was born.
1945 – John Helliwell, British musician (Supertramp), was born.
1947 David Brown, American musician (Santana), was born.
1950 – The Soviet Union and the People’s Republic of China signed a mutual defense treaty.
1951 Jane Seymour, British actress, was born.
1952 – King George VI was buried in St. George’s Chapel at Windsor Castle.
1959 Ali Campbell, British singer and songwriter (UB40), was born.
1960 Mikey Craig, British musician (Culture Club), was born.
1961 – Sabena Flight 548 crashed in Belgium, killing 73, with the entire United States Figure Skating team, several coaches and family.
1965 – A new red-and-white mapleleaf design was adopted as the flag of Canada, replacing the old Canadian Red Ensign banner.
1970 – A Dominican DC-9 crashes into the sea during takeoff from Santo Domingo, killing 102.
1971 – Decimalisation of British coinage was completed on Decimal Day.
1972 – Sound recordings were granted U.. federal copyright protection for the first time.
1976 – The 1976 Constitution of Cuba was adopted by the national referendum.
1978 New Zealand beat England in a cricket test for the first time.

1980 Television One and Television Two (formerly South Pacific Television) under the newly formed Television New Zealand went to air for the first time.
1982 The drilling rig Ocean Ranger sank during a storm off the coast of Newfoundland, killing 84 rig workers.
1989 Soviet Union invasion of Afghanistan: The Soviet Union officially announced that all of its troops have left Afghanistan.
1991 The Visegrád Agreement, establishing cooperation to move toward free-market systems, was signed by the leaders of Czechoslovakia, Hungary and Poland.
2003 Protests against the Iraq war occurred in over 600 cities worldwide. It is estimated that between 8 million to 30 million people took part, making this the largest peace demonstration in the history of the world.
StWC poster advertising the demonstration
2005 – YouTube, was launched in the United States.
Sourced from NZ History Online & Wikipedia
Valentines Day round up
February 14, 2010He may say – and believe – it’s better to know you’re loved every day than just once a year – but Valentines Day is also my birthday and my farmer gave me a beautiful bunch of flowers.
Over at In A Strange Land, Deborah writes about doing it right.
Busted Blonde’s Rock rocks.
Cactus Kate had computer problems but got flowers from a mystery man.
Andrei makes up for the lack of a duet in my list of top 10 (11) love songs with My Kind of Woman My Kind of Man.
And Quote Unquote has a bitter-sweet Valentine’s Day.
Another asado
February 14, 2010The couple at whose wedding I officiated yesterday work for us.
My farmer offered to help with the after-match lunch today and cooked a lamb:
He’s done it several times and got the recipe right – a smallish lamb, cooked very slowly over the embers of hot burning hard wood like manuka or blue gum.
It stays moist, is very tender and tastes delicious.
Skinny Marinky Dinky Dink
February 14, 2010Skinny Marinky featured on my list of top 10 love songs because it was the theme song of The Elephant Show which was a favourite when we were at the chidlren’s television stage of fmaily life.
Better than alright on the day
February 14, 2010The signs for the wedding rehearsal on December 30th weren’t good.
It was taking place at Elephant Rocks and the wind was so strong the marquee had been tide to a ute.
But the weather gods were only kidding. New Year’s Eve dawned clear and nearly calm and the wedding ceremony was able to take place as planned.
In contrast to December’s rehearsal, we couldn’t have had better weather for the one at the Mill House at Waianakarua on Friday. It was 26 degrees with no wind as we stood on lawn under the trees.
We didn’t even bother rehearsing plan B which was to move inside which I regretted when we woke up to rain yesterday. However, the wedding wasn’t until 2pm, by then the southerly had blown over and it was warm and calm on the lawn.
Perhaps it’s just been luck, but whatever has happened, or not, at rehearsals, it’s been better than alright on the day for all the weddings I’ve officiated at.
I’m not meaning just the weather, but everything else and that comes down to the attitude of the couples. They are there to commit themselves to each other and celebrate that with their family and friends. When they’re relaxed and happy about that everyone else is too.
When that happens, all’s right on the day, regardless of whether or not everything goes to plan. That provides happy memories for the couple and their guests and a wonderful start to the marriage.
Top 10 love songs
February 14, 2010Apropos of Valentines Day my top 10 love songs (in no particular order) are:
* My Love is Like a Red red Rose.
* The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face.
* You’ve Got A Friend.
* Bridge Over Troubled Water.
* Killg Me Softly With His Song.
* Your Song.
* Skinny Marinky Dinky Doo.
* All My Loving.
* Love Me Tender
* Love Is All Around.
* I’ll be there.
(Yes I know that’s 11, but you can’t have too much love).
Posted by homepaddock 










